10 Website Design Mistakes That Are Killing Your Conversion Rates

As a seasoned website designer and developer, I've encountered countless websites that unintentionally sabotage their own success. These website design mistakes affecting conversion rates are the heartbeat of your online business, and simple design mistakes can flatline your progress. Let’s dive into the common errors I've seen and discuss how to fix them so your site can thrive.

1. Ignoring Mobile Optimization

Remember the days when websites were only designed for desktops? Well, those days are long gone. Mobile optimization isn't just a nice-to-have; it's a must. I once had a client whose sales were stagnating despite heavy traffic. Turns out, their site was a nightmare on mobile devices. After a responsive redesign, their conversion rate jumped by 30%!

Tip: Use responsive design techniques to ensure your site looks great on any device. Using a mobile-first design approach allows you to introduce new features and functionality as the resolutions grow, resulting in a positive user experience on any device.

2. Overloading with Too Much Information

It’s tempting to throw every bit of information at your visitors, but a cluttered website can overwhelm them and drive them away. I advise clients to embrace whitespace and keep content digestible. Think of your website as a boutique, not a flea market. Employing lists and smaller bite-sized pieces of content broken up logically in sections and with accompanying imagery works to keep users interested, as well as informed!

Strategy: Simplify your content and layout to focus user attention on key elements, like your value proposition and call to action.

3. Using Non-Standard Navigation

Everyone loves creativity, but don’t reinvent the wheel with your site navigation. Users expect certain norms when browsing a site, like a horizontal menu at the top or a vertical one on the left. I once revamped a site with a “creative” circular navigation. It looked cool but confused users. We switched to a standard layout, and usability scores soared.

Best Practice: Stick to familiar navigation paths to keep your users comfortable and engaged.

4. Underestimating the Power of CTA Buttons

CTA buttons are your conversion drivers. They need to pop! I recall a project where changing the CTA from a drab grey to a vibrant orange increased clicks by over 20%. Experiment with size, color, and placement to find what best catches the eye. Make sizing and placement choices that follow the overall site hierarchy.

Quick Tip: Ensure your CTA buttons stand out and tell users exactly what to do.

5. Slow Loading Speeds

A slow website is a major turn-off. Nearly half of web users expect a site to load in two seconds or less. One of the quickest means of improving site load speed is by being mindful of file, and image sizes (file size and actual dimensions). Compressing and resizing images appropriately can result in huge performance gains. I worked with an e-commerce site that reduced its load time from :06 seconds to under :02, resulting in a dramatically improved bounce rate, and their page views nearly doubled.

Toolbox: Use tools like Google PageSpeed Insights to analyze and optimize your site speed.

6. Poor Use of Color and Contrast

Color isn't just aesthetic—it guides user behavior. Poor color choices can reduce readability and user interaction. Contrast, particularly, is crucial for readability. I’ve fixed numerous sites where simply increasing contrast led to better engagement and longer session times.

Color Wisdom: Choose a palette that reflects your brand, but also ensures good contrast and legibility while avoiding colors that evoke negative emotions or disabled user interface elements.

7. Lack of Trust Signals

Trust signals such as social proof (testimonials, reviews, social media influencers), certifications, and guarantees reassure users of your credibility. Adding verifiable testimonials, from trusted platforms like Google, Yelp, or Facebook, to a client’s homepage boosted their conversions by over 15%.

Implementation: Display badges of trusted organizations, user reviews, and money-back guarantees prominently to build user trust. And increase conversion rate.

8. Complicated Forms

Long, complex forms can scare away potential leads. One time, reducing a client's signup form from ten fields to four increased their conversions by over 25%. Keep forms simple and straightforward.

Form Tip: Only ask for information you absolutely need, and work to gain additional information via other marketing efforts after converting the user.

9. Ignoring SEO Principles in Design

SEO and design go hand-in-hand. A beautiful site that can’t be found is like a billboard in the desert. Use SEO-friendly design practices like proper HTML structure, fast loading times, and mobile-friendly layouts. This ensures search engines love your site as much as users do.

10. Failure to Test and Update

What works today might not work tomorrow. Continuous testing and updating are key to maintaining a high-converting website. Regular A/B testing can reveal invaluable insights into user preferences and behavior. Always be iterating.


Avoiding these common design mistakes can significantly enhance your site's conversion rates. Remember, your website is often your first impression—make it count. Review your site for these issues, or let a professional help you. Your online success depends on it. Think your website might be your weak link? Contact us for a comprehensive audit and we'll turn those weak spots into conversion hot spots!

Ready to grow your business and increase revenue? Dandy Digital specializes in modern web design, effective SEO, and comprehensive data analytics tailored to businesses like yours. Whether you need a custom website, SEO strategy, or data-driven insights, we've got you covered.

Let's collaborate to elevate your online presence and achieve your business goals. Contact us today to get started!

Thanks for reaching out to Dandy Digital! Your project means a lot to us, you should hear from us within 72 hours.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.